The Inner Steady

Kant’s Categorical Imperative: Test the Rule Behind Your Choice

By The Inner Steady Editorial Team

·

2–3 minutes

You promise to return a borrowed tool, though you already know you will not. The promise may solve today’s problem, but it depends on another person trusting a commitment you do not intend to keep. Kant’s categorical imperative asks us to examine the principle behind the action, not only the advantage it offers us.

Pedestrians and a cyclist take turns crossing a quiet city intersection.

A rule that is not just a personal exception

Immanuel Kant called the categorical imperative an unconditional moral principle: it applies independently of whether following it helps us get a particular reward. One formulation asks us to act only on a maxim—the principle we are following—that we could will as a universal law. In plain language: could this reason for acting make sense as a rule for everyone in relevantly similar circumstances?

The borrowed-tool example is not just “What if everyone did this?” Kant’s question is more exact: can the maxim of making a promise without intending to keep it be willed as a general rule, when the practice of promising depends on people taking promises seriously? If the rule undermines the very trust it uses, that is a reason to reject the maxim.

People are not merely instruments

Another formulation says to treat humanity, in yourself and others, always as an end and never merely as a means. This does not mean we may never rely on one another; cooperation routinely involves people helping with each other’s goals. The concern is bypassing someone’s ability to understand and choose—for example, deceiving them into a decision they could not knowingly accept.

The principle can be used as a reflection, not a calculator that automatically settles every hard case. People disagree about how to describe a maxim, what counts as a relevantly similar situation, and what duties apply when principles conflict. Naming those disagreements is part of ethical reasoning.

Three questions to ask

  • What principle am I using to justify this action?
  • Could I accept that principle if other people used it in similar circumstances?
  • Am I giving the people affected enough truth and choice to pursue their own purposes?

These questions are especially useful when convenience tempts you to make yourself an exception. For Kant’s broader argument and the different formulations of the categorical imperative, see the Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy entry on Kant’s moral philosophy. The site’s introduction to virtue ethics explores a different approach that asks what kind of character a choice expresses.

✎ Write