The Inner Steady

The Double Empathy Problem: When Misunderstanding Runs in Both Directions

By The Inner Steady Editorial Team

·

3–4 minutes
Two people in conversation, each rendered in a different visual style that overlaps into a shared pattern between them.
Two people in conversation, each rendered in a different visual style that overlaps into a shared pattern between them.

After a meeting, one person thinks they answered the question plainly. Their colleague remembers a clipped reply and a long silence, and concludes that the conversation went badly. Neither intended to be difficult. Each left with a different account of what the other meant. The double empathy problem offers a way to examine that gap without assuming it belongs entirely to one person.

The phrase was developed by autistic scholar Damian Milton to describe a mismatch in reciprocity between people who bring different ways of communicating, interpreting situations and anticipating one another. It is especially discussed in autistic and non-autistic interactions. “Double” points to the relational nature of a misunderstanding: both people may struggle to make sense of the other, even when their experiences of that struggle are not equal.

A mismatch is not a verdict about empathy

Empathy is often treated as if it were a single skill with one universally readable style. In real conversations, people infer interest from many cues: eye contact, tone, facial expression, speed of response, directness, or how much context someone supplies. Those cues are learned conventions, not transparent windows into another person’s concern. When two people rely on different conventions, a caring response can be missed—or a neutral one can be read as rejection.

This idea does not say that every misunderstanding is evenly shared, that intention cancels impact, or that a person should simply “try harder” to fit the majority style. Social settings often treat one communication style as the default and place more of the work of adaptation on autistic people. Access needs, sensory conditions, power differences and a history of being misunderstood all shape what a conversation costs.

What one study can—and cannot—show

In a 2020 study, 72 autistic and non-autistic adults took part in a story-sharing task. Nine groups of eight passed a story from person to person: some groups were autistic, some non-autistic, and some mixed. The researchers found a steeper loss of story details in the mixed groups, alongside lower ratings of rapport. They did not find a significant difference between the all-autistic and all-nonautistic groups.

That result is useful because it asks whether communication depends on the pairing and the setting, not only on an individual’s traits. It is not a universal rule for friendship, work or family life. The experiment used one task and a modest sample; it cannot predict how any two people will communicate. It is evidence for a question worth asking, not a score for judging a relationship.

Make the hidden rules easier to see

When a conversation feels confusing, try replacing guesses about personality with questions about the exchange itself. A few concrete changes can reveal whether the problem is a difference in expectations:

  • Ask for the request in direct language: “Would you like an answer now, or time to think?”
  • Say what a pause means for you instead of leaving someone to decode it: “I’m processing; I’m still listening.”
  • Check the interpretation before acting on it: “When you said ‘we’ll see,’ did you mean no, or that you need more information?”
  • Agree on practical conditions—written follow-up, a quieter room, more processing time—rather than treating them as personal favors.

These steps are invitations, not scripts everyone must use. A person can be curious about another’s perspective while still naming harm or setting a boundary. The aim is not to eliminate difference; it is to make fewer decisions on the basis of an untested assumption.

This relational lens sits beside, but is distinct from, mentalization: mentalization asks us to hold our interpretation of another mind lightly, while double empathy asks how different expectations shape an interaction between people. Milton’s original discussion appears in “On the ontological status of autism: the ‘double empathy problem’”. A later information-transfer experiment is available as an open-access research article.

After a difficult exchange, the most useful question may be more specific than “Who failed to understand?” Try asking: “Which expectation did we each bring, and how can we make it explicit next time?” That question leaves room for accountability, accommodation and mutual learning at once.

✎ Write