A colleague describes a pattern that has made it harder to do their job. The first reply is, “Are you sure you didn’t take it the wrong way?” The question may be sincere. But if the person’s account is discounted before anyone examines the evidence, something more than a disagreement about details may be happening.
Epistemic injustice is unfairness connected to a person’s role as someone who knows, remembers, interprets, and communicates. Philosopher Miranda Fricker describes two forms: a credibility gap that unfairly weakens a speaker’s word, and a gap in shared concepts that makes an experience difficult to name or explain.

Two ways a person can be unheard
Testimonial injustice occurs when prejudice leads a listener to give someone less credibility than the evidence warrants. A listener may assume that a person is unreliable, overemotional, or uninformed because of a social identity or status. The harm is not simply that the listener disagrees; it is that the speaker’s account receives an unfairly low starting weight.
Hermeneutical injustice happens when the shared language available to a person is inadequate for making sense of an important experience. A person may know that something is wrong while lacking a commonly recognized term that helps them explain it to others or even to themselves. New concepts can make previously isolated experiences intelligible.
These ideas do not mean that every disputed claim is true or that asking for evidence is disrespectful. They ask us to notice how credibility is assigned and whether people have a fair chance to make their experience understood. A careful listener can take a person seriously while still asking clarifying questions.
A practical way to listen
When someone brings you a difficult experience, slow down the move from account to verdict. You can start with: “What happened from your point of view?” or “What would help me understand the effect this had on you?” Then separate what you observed, what you inferred, and what remains uncertain.
- Check the credibility shortcut. Would I weigh this account differently if it came from someone with a different role or identity?
- Ask before correcting. Make room for detail before offering an alternative explanation.
- Do not require perfect wording. A person may need time to find language for a complicated experience.
- Keep accountability in view. Listening with care does not prevent you from checking facts or responding to harm.
If you are the listener, you do not need to agree immediately to show respect. If you are the speaker, you are not responsible for making every listener receptive. The point is to build conversations where people can contribute knowledge without having to overcome an avoidable credibility penalty first.
Where intellectual humility fits
A related skill is holding your interpretation firmly enough to examine it and lightly enough to revise it. Our guide to intellectual humility explores how openness can coexist with clear standards and boundaries.
Further reading: Miranda Fricker, Epistemic Injustice: Power and the Ethics of Knowing; Fricker, “Epistemic Justice and a Role for Virtue in the Politics of Knowing.”
Selected for this topic
Useful next reads
Four editorially reviewed guides chosen for relevance, not at random.
Relationships & supportWhat to Say When Someone Asks a Personal Question You Don’t Want to Answer
Relationships & supportWhat to Do When Someone Misunderstands You
Relationships & supportHow to Tell a Friend You Can’t Text All Day: A Kind, Clear Plan
Boundaries & assertivenessAssertive vs. Aggressive Communication: How to Tell the Difference