The Inner Steady

Second-Order Desires: What Does It Mean to Want to Want Something?

By The Inner Steady Editorial Team

·

2–3 minutes

“I want to keep scrolling, but I wish I wanted to practice.” That sentence contains two different wishes. One is directed at an immediate action; the other is about the kind of desire the person would like to guide them.

A musician tunes a cello at home while a phone rests face down across the room.

A desire about a desire

Philosopher Harry Frankfurt called a desire to do something a first-order desire. Wanting to check your phone, finish a song, or take a walk are examples. A second-order desire is a wish about which desires you want to have: you may wish to want the walk more than another hour of browsing.

Frankfurt made a further distinction. A second-order volition is a desire for a particular first-order desire to become effective—to be the desire that actually moves you to act. In the scrolling example, the person may not simply hope to enjoy practice; they may want their wish to practice to guide what they do next.

Reflection can clarify agency

The distinction helps explain why having an impulse does not automatically mean endorsing it. You can notice an immediate want without treating it as your whole identity. You can also discover that a wish you call “mine” is mostly an inherited expectation. Asking what you want to act on can reveal the difference between momentary appetite, considered commitment, and pressure from someone else.

This is not a test that divides people into good and bad desires. A second-order wish can be shaped by shame, social pressure, or unrealistic demands. And people may be ambivalent: part of you wants rest while another part wants to keep a commitment. Reflection does not always produce one pure answer.

A short reflection before acting

Try completing these sentences without correcting yourself: “Right now I want to…”; “I wish I wanted to…”; “If I chose according to my considered priorities, I might…”. Then ask whether the third sentence reflects a value you recognize or just another “should.” The goal is a more honest choice, not forcing the immediate desire to disappear.

Frankfurt develops the distinction in “Freedom of the Will and the Concept of a Person”. For a related psychological account of motivation, see the site’s guide to Self-Determination Theory.

✎ Write